When Jade and Riley get caught shoplifting, loss prevention officer Calvin Hardy brings the girls to the back room for questioning. These religious babes pray for forgiveness and want to right their wrongs. But the only way to do so is by listening and following every order Calvin gives them. It turns out that these horny teens stole a vibrator, and so Calvin wants to show these shy babes the pleasures they’ve been missing out on in life. Jade and Riley end up loving the experience and consider stealing again because, as it turns out, sinning is a whole lot of fun!